I know a lot of people aren't going to follow a 14 page thread, but in the "Warrior AoE threat" topic here on these forums there are several people trying to make the following case:
* Except for AoE threat Warriors are the BEST tanks in the game for EVERYTHING else.
We'd much rather see a discussion of *why* you think a particular tank is good or not good enough.
Polls typically contain very little information but a whole lot of bias. You can get around that with a large enough sample size, but that's almost impossible to get in a forum like this, and none of us really have the controls needed to for example prevent players from voting multiple times to skew the results.