#1 - Feb. 1, 2013, 11:36 p.m.
One Scary moment in WoW was back in Naxx 10, back in Wrath, I heard a "help me, save me" scream on the way to Thaddius, and when I heard "nooooo!" after that, my back was tied up. Even to this day, as I am trying to get T7 from Naxx25, I fear Thaddius. I then looked up his lore, it was very creepy.
How about you guys?